The Dragonlance Nexus

Printed From:
http://www.dlnexus.com/products/review/555.aspx

Reviews of 'The Black Talon'

The Black Talon

by Richard A. Knaak
Ogre Titans, Volume 1


Reviews of 'The Black Talon'

Here are the visitor reviews we have of The Black Talon. For more information about this title, please visit the item detail page.


Reviewer: BeezerMN

Rating: Stars

Black Talon by Richard A. Knaak is the first volume in the Ogre Titan trilogy. The other two books are scheduled to be called The Fire Rose set for release in December of 2008, and The Gargoyle King set for release in December 2009. This trilogy marks the return of Mr. Knaak to the Dragonlance universe since he last wrote Empire of Blood to finish off the Minotaur War trilogy. With Black Talon, Mr. Knaak proves that he has not missed a beat and if possible, has learned a few new tricks along the way. When I finished reading this book, I ended with the distinct impression that things are about to change in the Dragonlance universe. I will not say much on it, because I don't want to spoil things, but the change has been a long time coming and certainly a positive thing in my eyes.

When first picking up this novel, reads will notice it is not your typical Dragonlance book. In fact, this novel has about one hundred more pages. Mr. Knaak uses every one of those additional pages to his benefit. The plot of this book is multi-layered, deep, complex, and by all means interesting. The main plot centers around Golgren, whom fans will remember from previous books. The main story arc follows Golgren as he rises the social ladder of the ogres and how ruthless he has to be to hold any power. It also hints about what his plans are should he gain the power he is seeking. The first main sub-plot is that of the ogre titans and their plans both for working with Golgren and what their other plans are. Another sub-plot centers on the elf slave Idaria, and how she may be more than she presents herself to be. There is also a small sub-plot regarding a Solomnic Knight. Additionally, there are several other pieces mixed in that I can not talk about for fear of spoiling anything, but I must say this is one of the deepest Dragonlance books I have read in a long time. Mr. Knaak obviously has a vision for not only this trilogy, but a bigger vision for Dragonlance as a whole.

Traditional Dragonlance fans may be a little shocked at the overall 'feel' of this novel. This is not the classic Dragonlance novel. What I mean by that is it is much darker and grittier than the vast majority of Dragonlance books out there today. There seems to be a shift towards a darker, bloodier, more violent setting. The ruthlessness of the ogres does a lot to bring those feelings out, but I think it is more than that as well. I am really looking forward to seeing if this is a permanent shift or just for this particular trilogy. I for one am hoping at least some of this grittiness stays. Only time will tell though.

The characters in this are a very good mix, there is Golgren who is an ogre with one hand seeking to become a leader in a race that prides itself on its physical prowess. There is Dauroth who is the ogre titan leader and obviously has schemes of his own, whether they coincide with Golgren or not remains to be seen. Then there is Idaria, the elf slave who may have her own agenda. There are countless other characters as well, but in order to keep this review at a reasonable word count I won't bring them all up. Suffice it to say that there are many characters present in this novel, and each one has a purpose. In some novels I have read, there are characters simply to add filler and take up space. Not so with this novel. Every character has a reason for being in each scene, even if the reader is not privy to that reason right away. One thing I really like about the characters is the tremendous character development. All of the main characters develop rather significantly during the novel. I am really impressed due to the size of the novel how much actual development is in here. Also, Mr. Knaak did a very good job at giving each character their own voice and allowing the reader to see each character as unique.

My only criticism of this book, and this may be a personal bias, is there are many times when Mr. Knaak used the 'ogre tongue' for actual dialog. While this is a nice touch, there are times when he does this that the reader is left wondering what was just said. It was like watching a foreign movie with no subtitles. It took away, a little bit, from the overall feel of the novel due to the fact that I would then have to try and see if I could figure it out. Instead of the reading process being smooth there were small gaps.

Mr. Knaak's pacing and prose lend themselves well to this type of novel. He has shown with the Minotaur Wars trilogy that he can write strong characters among other strong characters. This novel proves no differently. While in reality this is only a four hundred page novel, once I finished I would have sworn it was at least six hundred just due to how much was really involved and conveyed with this novel. I really like the overall feeling that Mr. Knaak leaves the reader with, that being there are some changes ahead for the Dragonlance setting. Maybe that is just me, but hopefully that turns out to be true.

Overall, if you are a fan of Dragonlance this book needs to vault to the top of your must read list. There are many elements that fans will pick up on and recognize, but there is also a sense of newness that permeates this novel. It's very refreshing to read a Dragonlance novel like this. I also this that fantasy fans in general will enjoy this book as it's a very solid addition to the fantasy genre. While Margaret Weis and Tracy Hickman may be finishing their last Dragonlance book, Mr. Knaak has proved that he can carry that torch for years to come. I for one am eager to see where he takes us. This is certainly a book I will be recommending to others.


Reviewer: Tirinel

Rating: Stars

The Black Talon is a new book my writer Richard A. Knaak, who, as you might remember, wrote the Minotaur Wars trilogy. I assure you, when picking up this book, you won't regret a second.

The start opens with a chaotic scene of battle. I won't spoil too much for you, but Knaak does justice to everything here in means of descriptive, persuasive and bloody imagination of a writer and the reader. It simply blows your mind! People loving head rolling and blood spilling on every corner of the map can't miss that for their lives, and nearly all of it is fighting, but not just normal fighting; Richard A Knaak fighting. There's a big difference, my friends.

The book follows Golgren, a self dependant power seeking Ogre bent on taking Blode, having an alliance with the Solamnics, killing the Titans and on top of it all, finding traces of the High ogres. It's that packed, and it's full of twists and turns of danger and cruelty, mixed in with honour and self-sacrifice. Oh, and did I forget to mention the skeletons, minotaurs reaching Silvanost and looking to invade Blode? It's that packed, I say again.

For me, the only bad thing about the book itself was that sometimes, some of the words of the speakers ran just a teeny bit edgy; like in Harry Potter, for instance. But that was quite rare, and to be frank, I couldn't see any further alternative for Knaak. The vivid descriptions cloud those problems out, and with vivid battle scenes, nothing can go wrong dramatically, can it? No.

Another positive thing I would like to comment on is the descriptions of the animals in the Black Talon. You might have seen the infamous jibaraki on the front cover, but in the inside, they are numerous, carnivorous, and ready to rip some heads of for tea! Knaak really delivers well earned justice to these creatures in terms of imagination of their forms and names, their actions and thoughts; well done to him.

So, all in all, Knaak lovers simply cannot afford to not read this book. Buy it, and get immersed in the land of Golgren and Blode! Enjoy!


The views and opinions expressed in the reviews shown here are those of the reviewer(s) listed and do not necessarily reflect the ideas or opinions of the Dragonlance Nexus.

The Dragonlance Nexus does not publish any of the products listed in the Products section. While every effort has been made to ensure that the information presented is accurate, we cannot guarantee the accuracy of any listing. The Nexus is a member of the Associates program of Amazon.com and its international sites. Graphics are representational only.